Yavapai Gaming - August 2014

Home | Classifieds | Place an ad | Obituaries | Public Notices | Galleries | Opinions | Real Estate Search | Subscribe | 928 Media Lab | Yellow Pages | Contact Us
Chino Valley Review | Chino Valley, Arizona

home : latest news : local August 28, 2014

4/3/2014 7:43:00 AM
Driver who killed 2 gets 10 months; lawyer argues blood test was illegal
Matt Hinshaw/The Daily Courier, file
A member of the Chino Valley Police Department Accident Reconstruction Team inspects the scene of a double-fatal car wreck on Highway 89 just south of Chino Valley June 7, 2011.
Matt Hinshaw/The Daily Courier, file
A member of the Chino Valley Police Department Accident Reconstruction Team inspects the scene of a double-fatal car wreck on Highway 89 just south of Chino Valley June 7, 2011.
Scott Orr
Special to the Review

PRESCOTT, Arizona - Isaac Paul Browning, who in June 2011 was behind the wheel of a truck that crossed the center line of Highway 89 and ran head-on into an SUV, killing a man and woman, was sentenced on Tuesday to 10 months in the county jail and seven years' probation.

The victims were Nick Davirro, 91, and his wife Nona, 81, of Chino Valley. Both vehicles rolled on impact, and the Davirros were killed.

Browning, 21, from Prescott, was flown to Flagstaff Medical Center. An officer who spoke to Browning at the hospital said Browning told him he swerved to avoid an object on the roadway, but investigators were unable to find anything that might have been on the pavement prior to the accident.

A grand jury indicted Browning on two counts of manslaughter, one count of criminal damage, and two counts of driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs.

Browning accepted a plea offer last month that was very similar to the original charges, only one of the DUI charges was dropped.

Browning had a blood test after the collision which indicated both marijuana and oxycodone use, but attorney John Napper argued that the tests were done improperly, and that police didn't have the right to take Browning's blood because they had no probable cause and no warrant.

As evidence of the lack of probable cause, Napper quoted a Daily Courier story in which then-CVPD Commander Mark Garcia said the police did not believe alcohol or drugs were involved in the crash.

Napper contended that, if the case went to trial, the court would have to exclude the evidence of drug use because it was obtained in violation of Browning's Fourth Amendment rights.

"This case will be nearly impossible to prove absent the blood results," Napper argued in a court document.

That led to a situation in which the prosecution could either have gone to trial and taken the chance that Superior Court Judge Tina Ainley would have excluded the evidence of drug and alcohol impairment, or could offer a plea with the stipulation that punishment would be substantially lower than in similar cases in which the impairment was not questioned.

Deputy County Attorney Cynthia Spitler took the latter option, although she said in court, "I wish I could ask for more for punishment."

On Tuesday, the courtroom was packed with Browning's supporters. Noting that Browning had entered treatment for oxycodone addiction, which began with a prescription after an accident in 2010, Napper said, "Once he got into the treatment, he began to reach out to the community and the community is reaching back. That's why all these people are here."

Browning, whom Napper said never intended to shirk responsibility for the crash, tearfully told the victim's family members, "If I could sacrifice myself for them, I would. Nothing I can say will change what I did or bring them back, but I want you to know that my heart will always be heavy for them. I am so sorry for your loss."

"When two people lose their lives, the punishment in this county... would generally include a term of imprisonment," Ainley said, but with the "legal issues" surrounding the case, she said the victims' families would be better served by giving them closure rather than a protracted court battle.

Despite the evidentiary problems, the plea "couldn't be without a punishment component" of some kind, Ainley said, so she imposed 10 months in the county jail.

That will be followed by seven years of intensive probation, "which is essentially house arrest," Ainley said, and 400 hours of community service.

Follow the reporter on Twitter @AZNewsguy

Related Stories:
• How a superstar student-athlete became addicted to painkillers, killed 2 people in a car crash - and sought a measure of redemption
• Driver in double fatal Chino Valley wreck takes plea: Tested positive for oxycodone, marijuana
• Teen faces charges of manslaughter in Highway 89 collision
• Elderly Chino couple killed in head-on crash

    Recently Commented     Most Viewed
Mayor reports on water stewardship
Old Home Manor could see new life
American Legion Riders Post 40 donates picnic umbrellas to VA
Birth: Morgan Claire Peters
Chino Valley fire crews battle blazes in California, Washington

Reader Comments

Posted: Thursday, April 3, 2014
Article comment by: rosalind beatriz

He should be in prison for 5 years. the judge gave him a slap on the wrist!! No justice here, pray for the family of the people.

Article Comment Submission Form
Comments are not posted immediately. Submissions must adhere to our Use of Service Terms of Use agreement. The email and phone info you provide will not be visible to the public. Excessively verbose or rambling comments may not be posted. Please keep comments succinct; 200 words or less. Also, in order for us to reasonably manage this feature we may limit your comment entries to five(5) per day.
Submit an Article Comment
First Name:
Last Name:
Anti-SPAM Passcode Click here to see a new mix of characters.
This is an anti-SPAM device. It is not case sensitive.

Advanced Search

HSE - We want to hear from you
Find more about Weather in Chino Valley, AZ
Click for weather forecast

weather sponsored by

Find It Features Blogs Milestones Extras Submit Other Publications Local Listings
Classifieds | Place an ad | Public Notices | Galleries | Opinions | Real Estate Search | Subscribe | e-newsletter | RSS | Site Map | Contact Us
Yavapai Gaming - August 2014

© Copyright 2014 Prescott Newspapers, Inc. The Chino Valley Review is the information source for Chino Valley area communities in Northern Arizona. Original content may not be reprinted or distributed without the written permission of Prescott Newspapers, Inc. Prescott Newspapers Online is a service of Prescott Newspapers, Inc. By using the Site, cvrnews.com ®, you agree to abide and be bound by the Site's terms of use and Privacy Policy, which prohibit commercial use of any information on the Site. Click here to submit your questions, comments or suggestions. Prescott Newspapers Online is a proud publication of Western News&Info Inc.® All Rights Reserved.

Software © 1998-2014 1up! Software, All Rights Reserved